Return to Content

Megachurches in New England

Megachurches in New England
5 votes, 3.80 avg. rating (76% score)

Not everyone finds the same easy fit. Karen Tokmakoff, who began going to Grace in 1999, left after several years because it started to feel restrictive. “There’s so much mystery involved in faith and in the working of the Holy Spirit,” she says. “I believe my job is to love my neighbors the way Jesus would, but I wasn’t comfortable with the notion that I was supposed to go out and save them.” Of her new church in a nearby town, Tokmakoff says, “I feel more freedom to be who I am,” even though the scope of what it offers is more limited.

Megachurches, in particular, do tend to provide ready community in a welcoming, if supersized, environment. Cafés are customary, as are bookstores, gyms, and common areas furnished with overstuffed chairs and couches, where members gather long after the service has ended. Throughout the week, in addition to self-help groups and Bible studies, there are classes in art, drama, music, or household and fiscal management. Some churches have funds to help members through financial crises. The message is implicit: If you’re one of us, we’ll take care of you.

Ready-made community may be one reason why immigrants figure prominently in many evangelical congregations. Those with established religious ties in their countries of origin tend to build their own churches. According to Boston’s Emmanuel Gospel Center, recent counts, for instance, showed some 400 evangelical Brazilian churches in Massachusetts and southern New Hampshire, along with 15 Cambodian ones. Immigrants have also been drawn into existing churches: St. Matthew Trinity Lutheran Church in Pawtucket, Rhode Island, has reached out to the thousands of Liberians who live in the Ocean State, for example, and Faith has a sizable first-generation Latino population.

Jack Davis, a professor at Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary in South Hamilton, Massachusetts, says the sense of community experienced by evangelicals in the region is intensified by their relative scarceness. “There’s a feeling of being an outsider and a minority,” he says, with respect to the dominant Catholic religious presence and general secular culture. At the same time, evangelicals in the Northeast differ from those in other parts of the country because they’re less conservative. In general, they identify more with New England culture than with a Southern evangelical one, says Andrew Walsh: “The [cultural and political] evangelical package is unfamiliar to them. Most of them are not active religious-right types. They are, by and large, people who accept religious pluralism and think of religion as private.” For this reason, large national denominations have approached the Northeast “gingerly,” Walsh says.

The region’s younger evangelicals, in particular, tend to hold political views not typically associated with born-again Christianity. When Mike Mancini, who describes himself as pro-choice and unopposed to gay marriage (“It’s just a piece of paper to ensure rights,” he says), undertook his initial, marathon reading of the Bible, he discovered a mandate for social justice that underscored his own beliefs. “[Social justice] should be a priority of every Christian,” he says, “and liberal politics line up with that.”

On the national stage, evangelical politics have shifted in recent years. If the old stance zeroed in on individual morality, the new focus seems to be on broader issues: the environment, global poverty, human rights. The environment, and global warming in particular, has received particular attention of late. The Evangelical Climate Initiative, along with a statement signed by 86 church leaders, was released in February 2006, and in March 2008, 44 leading Southern Baptists issued a statement urging that denomination to be more aggressive in its response to environmental issues. Stewardship of the Earth, in Christian parlance, has become a rallying point for those who want a break with the religious right.

At the church level, the trend seems to be to step aside from politics and to focus on the individual, addressing issues like economic hardship and emotional distress in a personal way through hands-on teachings. This people-not-programs approach dovetails with an intention to draw individuals in one by one. As one Web site puts it: “Grace Chapel is an upbeat, energetic place that allows you to be you. Whatever your background, religious or not, wherever you are on your spiritual journey, committed or simply curious–you are welcome at Grace Chapel.”

That’s not to say that New England’s evangelical churches don’t proselytize. They do, and sometimes vigorously so–often through outreach by individual members, although the approach tends to be more subtle than the in-your-face witnessing of old. At the corporate level, Grace Chapel will, for example, issue open invitations to its holiday services through newspaper ads or mailed postcards, says Executive Pastor Bill Burke. “We’d rather show what we believe than actively convert,” Burke says. “The idea is to invite people in and to be who we are while they’re here. We want new members, but we don’t want to go about it in a forceful way.”

Many modern evangelical churches are modeled on the “seeker church”–among the best known of which are Rick Warren’s Saddleback Church in Lake Forest, California, and Bill Hybels’ Willow Creek Community Church in South Barrington, Illinois. Beyond their perhaps oversimplified image of targeting the unchurched and the spiritually hungry, seeker churches have for 50 years addressed the problems of everyday life while offering Biblically based assistance. In so doing they’ve blurred distinctions between the secular and the religious. Indeed, in a mission statement that sounds equal parts religion, motivational-speak, and Big Business, the Willow Creek Association (WCA) offers to provide its 12,000 member churches around the world with “life-changing experiences, tools, and innovations” and to assist them in reaching “their full redemptive potential,” which translates at least in part to large-scale congregation building.

Yet Frank Santora, for one, bristles at the label of “seeker church,” even though Faith, as well as Grace, belongs to the WCA and Santora makes no bones about wanting to grow Faith as big as possible. To him, the term connotes a watering-down of Biblical principle. He objects also to suggestions by conservative Christians that the portrayal of a loving God equates with a pick-and-choose, feel-good Christianity geared primarily toward marketing and unduly emphasizing pop psychology. Santora’s God, he says, wants His people to thrive, and, moreover, Christians should experience his presence directly in their daily lives.

Please Note: This information was accurate at the time of publication. When planning a trip, please confirm details by directly contacting any company or establishment you intend to visit.

Tags:
Yankee Magazine Advertising

Bring New England Home
plus, get the Tablet Edition FREE!

In this issue: A Real New England Christmas

  • Vintage Decorating Tips
  • Mission to Maine's Islands
  • Norman Rockwell's Stockbridge
  • Bonus! Holiday Cookbook
Subscribe Today and Save 44%

7 Responses to Megachurches in New England

  1. Sylvia Kinne January 15, 2009 at 10:01 am #

    You may have overlooked a wonderful church in Vermont, the Essex Alliance Church, which is the church my daughter’s family attends and loves – very family nurturing w/ programs for folks of all ages. I believe they have a membership of 1500 plus. Their “Christmas Spectacular” music program is filmed so far-flung family members who are unable to attend can enjoy it also. As I understand it, this church began as a small store-front gathering and has grown as mentioned above. Worth a look?

  2. Robert Faubel February 2, 2009 at 10:08 am #

    I just wanted to say thank you for doing this article. I’m one of the original members of the Faith Church which started as a small Bible study in the back of a doctor’s office. Having gone from an atheist cop to a police chaplain has surely changed my life. I have seen countless lives changed from people who really wanted to know the truth about God and I’m one of them. Our church is not the only one that is growing in this area. People are coming out of mainline denominations because these don’t see change in their lives and realize that religion is not the answer to life’s problems. It’s a relationship with God who created them!

  3. Denise Chamie February 5, 2009 at 3:09 pm #

    Amen to that Robert

  4. Jenifer Lewis February 10, 2009 at 3:20 pm #

    Anything that helps folks in their faith journey is to be celebrated. Interestingly, according to a recent article in “The Christian Century,” the migration can sometimes be from a megachurch to a more traditional one as well. A megachurch draws them in, and when they feel a craving for a more intimate worship experience, they find another church that provides it. This is particularly true for those who appreciate liturgy and classical music. Whichever way, it’s all good IMHO.

  5. Eura Olsen February 14, 2009 at 4:13 pm #

    I think this is a good thing. I attend a small church Open Bible We have a great pastor, people come and go ,some people can’t stand to hear the truth. I believe when you accept Jesus Christ, you are a new person andhave a hunger for his word,which speaks to youand gives you a joy you never knew.

  6. Kimberly LaCamera February 15, 2009 at 8:48 pm #

    I think Yankee magazine should do an article on Bethany Assembly of God in Agawam, MA. It may be a megachurch, but with a small town feeling to it. The church has programs for everybody, from the nursery to the seniors. All the kids know each other, so the parents know each other, if only to smile and say hi to. What a great church.

  7. Don Bayliss April 4, 2010 at 9:20 pm #

    One of the largest churches in New England that no one knows about is in the heart of Boston. http://www.jubileeboston.org/

    It is located in Mattapan. I had the opportunity to visit this church once with my wife before we were married many years ago when it was called New Covenant Church. They have over 5000 people that attend their services weekly.

Leave a Reply

We reserve the right to remove or edit comments that are offensive or disrespectful to our readers and/or writers, cannot be verified, lack clarity, or contain profanity. Your comments may be republished by Yankee Magazine across multiple platforms.

Register Sign In

©2013, Yankee Publishing Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Yankee Publishing Inc., | P.O. Box 520, Dublin, NH 03444 | (603) 563-8111