Return to Content

Gordon and Mary Hayward's Vermont Farmhouse | The Gardener's House

Yankee Plus Dec 2015


Gordon and Mary Hayward’s Vermont Farmhouse | The Gardener’s House
12 votes, 4.00 avg. rating (79% score)
Print Friendly

Over the past 30 years, a famous garden designer and his wife have transformed a dilapidated Vermont farmhouse into a study in harmony between indoors and out, where garden views are always in focus.

The Hayward home in West­minster West, Vermont.
Photo/Art by Keller + Keller
The Hayward home in West­minster West, Vermont.
The Hayward home around the time they bought it, in the early 1980s.
Photo/Art by Keller + Keller
The Hayward home around the time they bought it, in the early 1980s.

Town life never suited Gordon and Mary Hayward. They found that out firsthand in 1981, when they bought an 1850s-era white Cape in the heart of Saxtons River, Vermont. Over the next two years, the couple, both teachers at the time and the parents of a young boy, fixed up the old place and rebuilt the small gardens around it. But living on Main Street proved too busy for the Haywards, avid gardeners, both of whom had grown up on old farms—Gordon in New Hartford, Connecticut; Mary in the North Cotswold Hills of Gloucestershire, England. They wanted more country, more land. “We wanted a large garden, but we had no concept of what it would look like,” Mary says. “We just knew we wanted to grow things.”

Then, one day while driving to Brattleboro, where he taught high-school English, Gordon spotted a tired-looking 1780s Cape in Westminster West. The house, which sat on a rolling dirt road, looked so neglected that he couldn’t tell whether somebody was living in it, but he loved how it perched atop the slight rise of a south-facing hillside. He loved its attached barn and old pastures.

There was one catch: The home, still lived in and still in the hands of the family who had originally built it, wasn’t for sale. So the Haywards began talking to real-estate agents about finding a place like it. “We’d tell them that we were looking for an older place, built in the late 1700s, early 1800s, with some cleared land around it,” Gordon says. “Something that we could fix up and didn’t cost that much. And they’d say, ‘Yeah, and you want a stream and a pond and 11 acres of sugarbush, too, right?’ They’d heard it before.”

Over the next year they talked to anyone who would stand still for a minute about what they wanted. Then a teacher with whom Mary was working heard rumblings about a dilapidated Cape in Westminster West whose owner was looking to sell. It needed a lot of work, they were warned, but it had some land and sat on a little rise of land just off a pretty dirt road lined with big maples. “I knew exactly the house she was talking about,” Gordon says. “We made it down there in about a minute and a half.”

On a cold December day in 1983, the Haywards moved in. The house satisfied the couple’s eagerness to renovate. The plaster walls were crumbling, the house lacked central heat and insulation, and the well had long ago ceased working. The grounds were just as much of a project. Overgrowth and old car parts populated the acre of land. At one point the Haywards had 14 different brush fires going. Out of the barn and the woods they hauled seven large truckloads of scrap metal.

The Haywards’ kitchen, redesigned by Vermont cabinetmaker Steven Kenzer in 2009. “We wanted a kitchen that would settle quietly into this house built in the late 1700s,” Gordon says.
Photo/Art by Keller + Keller
The Haywards’ kitchen, redesigned by Vermont cabinetmaker Steven Kenzer in 2009. “We wanted a kitchen that would settle quietly into this house built in the late 1700s,” Gordon says.

Much of this early heavy lifting the Haywards did themselves. They stripped plaster walls of tattered wallpaper, refinished them, and painted them white; they seeded newly cleared grounds with grass. Color choices and experimental plantings could wait. “It was a matter of getting it to a point where we could manage it,” Mary says, “so we could keep it under control.”

“At one point, I got up on the metal roof, which was just covered with rust, and I wire-brushed the whole exterior of the house—roof and sides,” Gordon says. “We were driven.” With a laugh, Mary adds, “We were into work.”

The pool garden on the north side of the barn.
Photo/Art by Keller + Keller
The pool garden on the north side of the barn.

During those early years, the property became an experimental site for Gordon, who quit teaching in 1985 and launched himself as one of the country’s leading garden designers, with landscape projects that have taken him all over the United States. He’s the author of 11 books, including Your House, Your Garden, which was lauded by the American Horticultural Society as a top title in 2004, and he’s been a regular contributor to Horticulture and Fine Gardening magazines.

“When we bought this place, we had an opportunity to express what interested us,” Gordon says. “It became our laboratory, where we learned about plants, where we learned about design.”

Ian Aldrich


Ian Aldrich


Senior editor of Yankee Magazine: Ian, a native New Englander who has worked and freelanced for Yankee for the past decade, writes feature stories, home pieces, and helps manage the magazine's up-front section, First Light. His stories have ranged from exploring the community impact from a church poisoning in a small town in northern Maine to dissecting the difficulties facing Nantucket around its problems with erosion. In addition to his connection to Yankee, Ian worked as a senior editor of Cincinnati Magazine for several years.

3 Responses to Gordon and Mary Hayward’s Vermont Farmhouse | The Gardener’s House

  1. Peggy Farabaugh April 2, 2014 at 2:44 pm #

    Thank you Ian for an inspiring article about Gordon and Mary’s beautiful home. Last year we were lucky enough to persuade Gordon to design the landscaping for a 200+ year old farmhouse we converted to a showcase for Vermont made furniture and home decor. He did an incredible job and we can hardly wait for everything to come into bloom for the first time. One thing readers might want to note is that traditional stonework is often a signature part of Gordon’s garden designs. He recommended Torben Larsen of Windham Growers in Putney, VT to do our stonework and it’s remarkable.

  2. Amy Skrzek November 16, 2014 at 9:47 pm #

    Great job with the house and land/garden. However, not all homes in New England are “Capes” The one in the pictures provided (Where Gordon and his wife live) was built in the late 18th cen and from the looks of it is built in the Georgian Style. Their previous home was built in the 1850’s, I would venture a guess that it was Greek(?). The term “Cape” for a house was created post WWII for the smaller homes being built that resembled those found in New England especially the Cape which were built (mainly) in the Georgian Style and were shingle cladded (obviously not all of them…) SO, it was annoying that all three or four homes were referred to as Capes; it does little for the imagination when all I can think of is a post-WWII “Cape” in suburbia…

  3. Deborah Pyle November 17, 2014 at 5:23 am #

    So awesome! Perfect place to live!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Leave a Reply

We reserve the right to remove or edit comments that are offensive or disrespectful to our readers and/or writers, cannot be verified, lack clarity, or contain profanity. Your comments may be republished by Yankee Magazine across multiple platforms.

Register Sign In

©2015, Yankee Publishing Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Yankee Publishing Inc., | P.O. Box 520, Dublin, NH 03444 | (603) 563-8111

< Prev

Wolfeboro, New Hampshire Properties | House for Sale

This tidy cottage sits on Lake WinnipesaukeeLocated on the eastern side of New Hampshire’s largest lake, Wolfeboro has always been among ...

Related Articles

Next >

How to Make a New House Look Old | Advice from Bob Vila

Bob Villa Bob Vila is the former host of several home-improvement TV programs, including This Old House ...

Related Articles